Trump AI Pope Image Draws Criticism - ListenHub

Trump AI Pope Image Draws Criticism

May 4

Frombbc

Trump's AI Pope Image Sparks Outrage Trump faced criticism for posting an AI image of himself as Pope after Francis's death, drawing Catholic condemnation and international disapproval despite White House defense.

Trump Criticized for AI Pope Image

The Controversy: Donald Trump posted an AI-generated image of himself as the Pope on official White House social media. This action has drawn criticism, especially from Catholics.
Timing: The post was made as Catholics mourn the death of Pope Francis and prepare for the selection of a new Pope. Pope Francis died on April 21.
Catholic Reaction: The New York State Catholic Conference accused Trump of mocking the faith.
- The NYSCC stated, "There is nothing clever or funny about this image, Mr President... We just buried our beloved Pope Francis and the cardinals are about to enter a solemn conclave to elect a new successor of St Peter. Do not mock us."
Trump's Comment: The post comes days after Trump joked to media: "I'd like to be Pope."
Image Details: The AI-generated image shows Trump wearing a white cassock and pointed mitre, traditionally worn by a bishop, along with a large cross.
Past Offenses: The article mentions that former President Joe Biden also faced criticism from some Catholics for making the sign of the cross at a pro-abortion access rally.
Vatican's Response: Vatican spokesman Matteo Bruni declined to comment on Trump's post. The Vatican is preparing for a conclave to choose Francis's successor.
International Reaction: Italian former Prime Minister Matteo Renzi called the image offensive and insulting to institutions.
White House Defense: Press secretary Karoline Leavitt defended Trump, stating he paid his respects to Pope Francis and has been a "staunch champion for Catholics and religious liberty."
Archbishop Dolan's Disapproval: New York Archbishop Timothy Dolan, who is friendly with Trump, expressed his disapproval of the image, calling it a "brutta figura" (bad impression)

Outline

Trump's AI Pope Image Sparks Outrage Trump faced criticism for posting an AI image of himself as Pope after Francis's death, drawing Catholic condemnation and international disapproval despite White House defense.

Trump Criticized for AI Pope Image

The Controversy: Donald Trump posted an AI-generated image of himself as the Pope on official White House social media. This action has drawn criticism, especially from Catholics.
Timing: The post was made as Catholics mourn the death of Pope Francis and prepare for the selection of a new Pope. Pope Francis died on April 21.
Catholic Reaction: The New York State Catholic Conference accused Trump of mocking the faith.
- The NYSCC stated, "There is nothing clever or funny about this image, Mr President... We just buried our beloved Pope Francis and the cardinals are about to enter a solemn conclave to elect a new successor of St Peter. Do not mock us."
Trump's Comment: The post comes days after Trump joked to media: "I'd like to be Pope."
Image Details: The AI-generated image shows Trump wearing a white cassock and pointed mitre, traditionally worn by a bishop, along with a large cross.
Past Offenses: The article mentions that former President Joe Biden also faced criticism from some Catholics for making the sign of the cross at a pro-abortion access rally.
Vatican's Response: Vatican spokesman Matteo Bruni declined to comment on Trump's post. The Vatican is preparing for a conclave to choose Francis's successor.
International Reaction: Italian former Prime Minister Matteo Renzi called the image offensive and insulting to institutions.
White House Defense: Press secretary Karoline Leavitt defended Trump, stating he paid his respects to Pope Francis and has been a "staunch champion for Catholics and religious liberty."
Archbishop Dolan's Disapproval: New York Archbishop Timothy Dolan, who is friendly with Trump, expressed his disapproval of the image, calling it a "brutta figura" (bad impression)

Script

Mia: Okay, so check this out. Trump drops an AI-generated picture of himself as the Pope, like, right after Pope Francis passes? Seriously? It’s like showing up to a funeral in a clown suit, right?

Mars: Dude, totally! It's like... imagine going to a super somber memorial service and someone starts juggling flaming torches. That's pretty much how a lot of folks in the Catholic community saw it.

Mia: But why is the timing *such* a big deal? I mean, AI can crank out anything these days. Is it really that offensive?

Mars: Well, yeah, AI can do anything, but context is king. Pope Francis croaked it, like, the 21st, right? And the cardinals were about to, you know, go into that secret conclave to pick the next guy. It’s a *huge* deal, super serious. Think like, I don’t know, the Oscars, but like, way more hush-hush. Then BAM! Trump in white robes and the pointy hat. Not a good look.

Mia: Right, right, gotcha. So, what were the bigwigs, like, the Catholic higher-ups saying?

Mars: The New York State Catholic Conference basically lost it. They were like, There’s nothing funny about this picture. We just buried our Pope, and the cardinals are about to pick a new one. Show some respect!” Basically, Don't be a jerk.

Mia: Yikes! Ouch. Did Trump actually, you know, apologize or anything?

Mars: Nah, no direct my bad. He had joked to reporters earlier, “I’d like to be Pope,” so maybe he thought it was just a funny bit. But when it went official White House channels, that's when it really went next level.

Mia: Huh. So, Vatican-wise? Did they weigh in?

Mars: Nope. Nada. The Vatican spokesman just straight-up avoided it. Said they were too busy getting ready for the conclave. It's like when someone starts trash-talking your family at Thanksgiving dinner, you just pretend you didn't hear them.

Mia: Okay, so who else jumped in the fray?

Mars: Oh, tons of people. Italy's ex-Prime Minister, Renzi, called it offensive and insulting. Even Archbishop Dolan, who's basically best buds with Trump, called it a brutta figura, which is Italian for, like, a really bad look.

Mia: So, you’ve got the “mockery!” camp, and then the White House kinda doubling down?

Mars: Exactly! The press secretary said he's been respectful of the late Pope Francis and that Trump’s a staunch champion for Catholics. It’s like saying, I love animals, I just set this one on fire for fun.

Mia: Woah! That's...intense. Does stuff like this actually *work* for Trump though?

Mars: In some corners, yeah, it fires up his base – the folks who dig his wild antics. But among religious communities, it can seriously backfire. You end up looking like you think faith is some kind of dress-up game.

Mia: Totally. So, bottom line, what's the takeaway here?

Mars: Messing around with sacred stuff is a gamble. It might grab attention, but it can really alienate the people who think faith is a serious deal, not just a chance for a meme.