Teacher Bai's FCA "Three Paths" Model: Simplifying Coffee Evaluation
Y “Agatha coffee beans” B
3
7-12Owen: You know, I've always felt that professional coffee tasting is this incredibly complex, almost mystical world. Is there a way to simplify it for the rest of us?
Olivia: Well, there's a fascinating system called the Three Paths Model that does exactly that. The core idea is to give people like coffee farmers or exporters, who aren't professional cuppers, a simple map to judge a bean's potential.
Owen: A map for coffee flavors. I like that. So it's about making that exclusive knowledge accessible to everyone along the supply chain.
Olivia: Precisely. It translates those high-level professional terms into something tangible that helps them understand what they actually have and where it fits in the market.
Owen: Okay, let's get into the map then. What are these three paths? Can you break down the Yellow, Red, and Purple for me?
Olivia: Absolutely. The Yellow path is the Golden Path. Think of it as a perfectly balanced coffee, a well-written article with a great beginning, middle, and end. It’s consistent, low-risk, and a crowd-pleaser.
Owen: Got it. So that’s the safe bet. What about the other two?
Olivia: The Red path is the Exploration Path. These coffees might have small, controllable flaws, but they also have really interesting, standout characteristics. Think of a bean with a stunning floral aroma that then shifts to an unexpected, slightly tart fruit note. It's for brands that want to offer a unique surprise.
Owen: And the Purple path?
Olivia: That's the Aroma Path. This is the tricky one. It has a massive, beautiful aroma right at the start, but the flavor itself is hollow and unstable. It's like an embroidered pillow—looks great, but there's no substance inside. These are risky for a brand's reputation.
Owen: That's fascinating. So it's not just about good versus bad, but about the structure of the flavor itself.
Olivia: Exactly. It's about whether the experience has integrity beyond that first sniff.
Owen: That distinction between the Exploration and Aroma paths is the real eye-opener for me. It suggests that a flaw on the Red path can actually be a selling point for a niche brand, while the Purple path is a trap. It’s not about perfection, but about finding the right story for the right bean.
Olivia: You've nailed it. Understanding the inner substance, the skeleton of the flavor, is the whole game.
Owen: So, this system is great for beginners. But what about the seasoned pros? Is there a next level?
Olivia: There is. For them, there's the Flavor Expert System. It's less about which path and more about developing what's called structured expressiveness.
Owen: Structured expressiveness. What capabilities does that system focus on?
Olivia: It hones three key skills. First is Identification—knowing when and where aromas appear. Second is Structure—assessing the balance and consistency, finding any breakpoints where the flavor drops off. And third is Expression—clearly communicating all of this to a buyer.
Owen: So it’s about moving from just liking a coffee to being able to objectively analyze it and explain that analysis to someone else.
Olivia: Right. It’s about building a case for a coffee's value based on data, not just personal preference.
Owen: I can see how the radar chart you mentioned would be a game-changer here. Mapping out things like acidity and sweetness turns a subjective feeling into a visual, objective language. You can literally see why a coffee works or doesn't.
Olivia: Exactly. It takes the I just feel like... out of the equation and allows for precise, data-driven conversations and training. It's how you calibrate an entire team of tasters.
Owen: That's incredibly powerful. I can imagine how an organization like the Cup of Excellence could use this to add even more depth to their evaluations.
Olivia: It helps them build a more multi-dimensional story for why those winning coffees are truly exceptional, beyond just a simple score.
Owen: So for our listeners, the everyday coffee lovers or people new to the industry, how can they tap into all this?
Olivia: The good news is that this isn't some secret art. There are offline workshops and online courses available. The whole point is to show that sensory judgment is a skill anyone can learn with the right method.
Owen: That's really encouraging. It democratizes the whole process of appreciating coffee on a deeper level.
Olivia: It really does. At the end of the day, whether it's the simple Three Paths for a farmer or the detailed expert system for a judge, it's all about one thing: simplifying coffee evaluation to reveal the true nature and potential of the bean.